The Meaning Behind The Song: Toby Fox vs Scott Cawthon by Mr. Jay (RB)

Undertale creator Toby Fox and Five Nights at Freddy’s creator Scott Cawthon clash in a rap battle in the song “Toby Fox vs Scott Cawthon” by Mr. Jay (RB). This rap battle, which is part of the JMB Rap Battles series, aims to determine who the better indie game developer is.

The song starts with Toby Fox taking the first verse. Fox references the concept of “Acting” in games and how it falls flat without the support of theorists like MatPat. He then criticizes Cawthon, playfully referring to him as a “Mad Dummy” and commenting on his character naming choices. Fox asserts that he will maintain his integrity and produce quality content. He acknowledges that his own game, Undertale, may not have received as much fame as Cawthon’s Five Nights at Freddy’s series, but he believes it is still a valuable and meaningful creation.

The interlude features a snippet of dialogue from Cawthon’s game, Five Nights at Freddy’s, where a character warns the player about their poor choice of rival.

Cawthon retaliates in his verse, addressing Fox directly. He suggests that Fox could benefit from learning from him, the “pro”, rather than indulging in anime discussions. Cawthon boasts about his work ethic and financial success, humorously stating that there is no “Pause Button” when it comes to making money. He then makes a reference to Undertale’s dating mechanics, suggesting that Fox’s characters beg for inappropriate fan content. Cawthon concludes by pointing out the age difference between them.

Fox responds in the third verse, refusing to show mercy. He asserts that Cawthon’s previous fame has faded and compares it to the critical reception of FNAF World. Fox uses wordplay with the phrase “steak to the face” to imply that Cawthon’s attempts at retaining relevance have backfired. However, Fox acknowledges the success of Cawthon’s book series “Silver Eyes”.

Cawthon fires back in the fourth verse, remarking on Fox’s social media presence and likening him to a guinea pig in Andrew Hussie’s basement. He asserts that he has a moral compass, even though he uses strong language. Cawthon threatens to put Fox through pain, invoking a religious reference.

Fox returns with the fifth verse, boasting about the challenges he has overcome and referencing the gory and morbid themes in his game, Undertale. He playfully advises Cawthon to press the “B button” (a reference to gaming) if he wants to deliver a solid blow. Fox also mentions the collaborative effort behind Five Nights at Freddy’s, crediting two writers for its success. He then uses wordplay with the phrase “Radiation” to emphasize the intensity of his bars and claims a victorious outcome.

Cawthon delivers the final verse, dismissing Fox as an amateur and criticizing the similarities between Undertale and Earthbound. He mentions his philanthropic efforts and contrasts them with Fox’s supposed lack of success and involvement in the real world. Cawthon comments on the multiple versions of the song “Megalovania” in Undertale before concluding with a reference to the fall of Undertale compared to his continued success.

The song ends with a short outro, leaving the winner of the rap battle up to interpretation, and teasing future rap battles. The song was released on March 18, 2017, and can be found on the album JMB Rap Battles (OLD) (2023).

Personally, this song holds a special meaning for me. As a fan of both Undertale and Five Nights at Freddy’s, it was fascinating to see the creators engage in a friendly yet competitive rap battle. The lyrics showcase the unique qualities and success of each game, while also playfully poking fun at certain aspects. It’s a creative way for the creators to express their admiration and rivalry in a fun and entertaining manner.

This rap battle also serves as a reminder of the impact independent game developers have had on the gaming industry. Both Toby Fox and Scott Cawthon have created highly successful and influential games that have resonated with millions of fans worldwide. Their innovative and imaginative storytelling has captivated players and inspired a new generation of game developers.

In conclusion, “Toby Fox vs Scott Cawthon” is a rap battle song by Mr. Jay (RB) that showcases the friendly rivalry between the creators of Undertale and Five Nights at Freddy’s. The lyrics cleverly highlight the strengths and accomplishments of each game while offering a fun and engaging listening experience for fans. It’s a testament to the creativity and impact of independent game developers and the enduring popularity of their creations.